Thoughts and Prayers Are Not Enough
While there’s truth in the idea that life has improved for many gay people, improvement doesn’t equate to equality or safety. Tragic events like Matthew Shepard’s murder in the 1990s and the Pulse shooting in 2016 are stark reminders of the deep-seated hatred and hostility the LGBTQ+ community still endures.
While the Pulse nightclub shooting stands as a painful chapter in the LGBTQ+ community's history, this tragedy should ignite a collective call to action—for both our community and our allies—to go beyond thoughts and prayers. Real change requires a commitment to tolerance and acceptance, especially given the current political climate where inflammatory rhetoric can foster a culture that normalizes and justifies violence.
Pulse: More Than a Nightclub
Pulse, a gay nightclub in Orlando, Florida, was founded by Barbara Poma and Ron Legler and opened its doors on July 2, 2004. Named to honor Barbara's brother John, who died from AIDS in 1991, the name symbolized keeping his "pulse" alive.
More than a dance club, Pulse served as a vital community hub. It supported initiatives for HIV prevention, breast cancer awareness, and immigrant rights while collaborating with advocacy groups like Come Out with Pride, Equality Florida, and the Zebra Coalition.
Orlando itself is home to a large Hispanic and LGBTQ+ population, enhancing the significance of Pulse's role in the city. As of 2022, 34% of Orlando’s population identified as Hispanic, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.
While specific data on the LGBTQ+ population is limited, the Williams Institute estimates that 5% of Orlando residents—approximately 93,000 people—identify as LGBTQ+. In 2021, Orlando also ranked as the most LGBTQ-friendly travel destination in the United States, according to ParkSleepFly.
The Troubled Background of Omar Mateen
29-year-old Omar Mateen, the Pulse nightclub shooter, had a turbulent history marked by behavioral issues, troubling ideologies, and missed red flags. Born in New York to Afghan-American parents, Mateen moved to Florida as a child, where he struggled academically and faced frequent suspensions for disciplinary issues. Early accounts from classmates described him expressing support for violence and extremist figures, even as a teenager.
As an adult, Mateen pursued a career in security, working for G4S Secure Solutions from 2007 to 2016. However, questions emerged about the validity of his psychological screening for the job. G4S initially claimed that a licensed psychologist had cleared Mateen, but investigations revealed this clearance was issued under questionable circumstances, with records showing errors and ties to a psychologist connected to Mateen’s family. Despite exhibiting alarming behavior, including workplace threats, Mateen retained his position and was transferred instead of being terminated.
In addition to his job history, Mateen had been investigated by the FBI twice. In 2013, he made inflammatory claims about ties to terrorist groups while working as a security guard, and in 2014, he was linked to an individual who had carried out a suicide bombing in Syria. Both investigations were closed after Mateen was deemed not to be a “credible threat.”
Mateen’s personal life was equally tumultuous. He married twice, with both relationships reportedly strained by his abusive behavior, and had a son with his second wife, who left him in late 2015.
In the weeks leading up to the Pulse shooting, Mateen legally purchased firearms, including a semi-automatic rifle and a handgun. He also attempted to buy body armor and large quantities of ammunition but was turned away by a suspicious shop owner. Prior to the attack, Mateen expressed extremist views on social media, condemning Western society and invoking the name of the Islamic State.
The Night of the Pulse Nightclub Shooting
On the night of June 11, 2016, Pulse was hosting its popular Latin Night, drawing a crowd of approximately 320 people. As the night turned into the early hours of June 12, the club was winding down, and last-call drinks were being served. At around 2:02 a.m., Mateen entered the club armed with a semi-automatic rifle and a handgun, bypassing a security guard and immediately opening fire on the crowd.
Initially, the gunfire was mistaken by some patrons for part of the music or pyrotechnics. However, chaos quickly ensued as Mateen continued shooting indiscriminately. Some sought cover under furniture, while others hid in bathrooms. Imran Yousuf, a Marine Corps veteran working as a bouncer, heroically opened a locked door, enabling approximately 70 people to escape.
Within two minutes, additional police officers arrived and engaged Mateen, who retreated deeper into the club, taking hostages in one of the bathrooms. In less than five minutes, Mateen had fired approximately 200 rounds. Amid the violence, terrified patrons called 911 or texted loved ones for help. Police worked to evacuate as many people as possible, with nearly all injured individuals outside the bathrooms rescued by 2:35 a.m.
Negotiations with Mateen stretched into the early morning. He called 911 and local news outlets, claiming allegiance to ISIS and making threats about explosives, which were later determined to be false. After hours of failed negotiations and growing concerns for the safety of the remaining hostages, police launched a final operation. At 5:07 a.m., SWAT officers breached the building using an armored vehicle and engaged Mateen in a firefight, ultimately killing him by 5:17 a.m.
The Aftermath of the Pulse Nightclub Shooting
The Pulse nightclub shooting claimed the lives of 49 people and left 53 others injured, with a significant number of victims being of Hispanic descent, including many who identified as Puerto Rican. The attack not only devastated the LGBTQ+ and Latinx communities but also underscored ongoing issues related to gun violence, hate crimes, and the challenges of ensuring public safety in the face of such threats.
The tragedy stands as the deadliest act of violence against the LGBTQ+ community in U.S. history, surpassing the 1973 UpStairs Lounge arson attack. It was also the deadliest terrorist attack on U.S. soil since September 11, 2001, and, at the time, the deadliest mass shooting by a single perpetrator until the Las Vegas shooting in 2017.
In the aftermath, questions arose about Omar Mateen's motives. While some speculated he might have targeted Pulse due to anti-LGBTQ+ animus, investigations later suggested the club was chosen for its lack of security rather than its clientele. Mateen’s father claimed his son was angered by seeing a gay couple kiss in public, which could have played a role. Regardless, the shooting was widely recognized as both an act of terrorism and a hate crime, emblematic of deeply ingrained prejudices.
Reactions to the shooting revealed the persistence of anti-LGBTQ+ hate. While many expressed solidarity, some celebrated the violence, echoing the rhetoric of the AIDS crisis when hate speech dehumanized the victims. Online, hateful language proliferated, highlighting how deeply some factions of society still stigmatize LGBTQ+ lives.
National and Local Responses
As the attack unfolded, Governor Rick Scott and Orlando Mayor Buddy Dyer declared states of emergency. President Obama ordered federal resources to support the investigation and community recovery. Flags were lowered to half-staff nationwide, and law enforcement increased security at LGBTQ+ landmarks and Pride events.
The tragedy also reignited debates around gun control. Democratic lawmakers staged a 15-hour filibuster in the Senate, advocating for measures to prevent individuals on terrorist watchlists from purchasing firearms. However, these efforts were defeated largely along party lines.
The shooting also shed light on then-discriminatory blood donation policies. In the wake of the attack, many in the LGBTQ+ community sought to donate blood for victims. However, the FDA's longstanding restrictions on blood donations from gay and bisexual men, which were eventually lifted in May 2023, drew widespread criticism, emphasizing the policy's basis in stigma rather than science.
A Call to Remember and Act
The Pulse nightclub shooting was a heartbreaking reminder of the hate and violence that still targets the LGBTQ+ community, underscoring the deadly consequences of prejudice and the urgent need to confront hate in all its forms.
In the years since, we’ve seen an increase in inflammatory political rhetoric, threats against LGBTQ+ individuals, and a rise in anti-LGBTQ+ legislation. These hostile forces can foster environments where violence becomes more likely, leaving many of us questioning what we can do in the face of such overwhelming challenges.
While we may not be lawmakers or able to change every opinion, there is power in our collective action. We must honor the memories of those lost at Pulse by continuing to raise our voices against inequality, violence, and the injustices that threaten our community. Sharing stories like those of the Pulse victims with friends, family, and allies helps keep their memories alive while building a stronger network of support. Allies play a critical role in amplifying our message and advocating for change alongside us.
Yes, these conversations are difficult and uncomfortable, but they are necessary. The Pulse nightclub shooting reminds us why we need equal protections and why we cannot tolerate hate. Remembering this tragedy preserves its significance as a catalyst for action and advocacy, reinforcing that we must continue to stand up for our community, our rights, and our safety.
Let’s keep informing, organizing, and working toward a future where tragedies like Pulse are unthinkable—a future where every LGBTQ+ person can live authentically without fear. Together, we can honor the past and fight for a better, more just tomorrow.
And remember: every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 61. The Pulse Nightclub Shooting.
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
