What’s the Sitch?
In the evolving landscape of modern relationships, gay men are increasingly navigating the complexities of situationships—romantic dynamics that fall somewhere between casual encounters and committed partnerships. Unlike traditional relationships with clear labels and expectations, situationships often involve emotional or physical intimacy without the commitment or exclusivity that define more formal unions.
As the definitions of love and connection continue to shift, gay men find themselves in these undefined relationships, embracing the freedom they offer while grappling with the uncertainty that comes with their ambiguity. While situationships aren't inherently good or bad, they can negatively impact mental health if both partners aren't on the same page about their expectations and boundaries.
Understanding Situationships: A Modern Romantic Dynamic
A situationship is a romantic relationship between two people who are more than just friends but have not yet defined themselves as a couple. The term, as defined by the Cambridge Dictionary, refers to a relationship that exists in a gray area—more intimate than a friendship but lacking the commitment and exclusivity of a formal partnership.
This is distinct from a friends-with-benefits arrangement, as noted by Drawing Down the Moon, a London-based personal matchmaking agency with over 40 years of experience in the industry. While both scenarios may involve emotional or physical intimacy, the key difference lies in the level of commitment and emotional involvement. A situationship, unlike a friends-with-benefits relationship, is characterized by its ambiguity. A friend-with-benefits relationship is typically a casual sexual arrangement between friends, where the emotional connection is secondary to the physical aspect.
Situationships, on the other hand, can have an emotional component, which adds complexity to the relationship. According to psychologist Susan Albers, writing for Cleveland Clinic in 2023, the core feature of a situationship is ambiguity. It exists without the obligations or exclusivity typical of committed relationships and lacks clear boundaries. While it may involve elements of both friendship and romance, the relationship remains undefined, allowing individuals to enjoy some of the benefits of a traditional relationship without the commitment.
Examples of situationships are varied and often reflect these blurry boundaries. They may include scenarios like a person you see when they're in town for work, a post-breakup rebound that hasn’t yet transitioned into something serious, or a passionate affair that ends when a vacation does. Other examples might involve a casual sexual relationship with someone you rarely contact, or a convenient "plus one" for events, but who wouldn't be introduced to your family. In all these cases, the relationship is defined by its lack of clarity, with no firm commitment to the future.
Signs of a Situationship: Key Characteristics to Look For
Understanding what a situationship is helps clarify the potential signs of one. According to Dr. Albers, there are five key characteristics commonly found in most situationships:
- No Labels or Exclusivity
A defining feature of situationships is the absence of a "define the relationship" (DTR) conversation. As Albers notes, you may not have explicitly discussed the nature of your connection, and one or both partners may still be seeing other people. - Lack of Clear Boundaries
Expectations, both large and small, are essential in defining any relationship. In situationships, there’s often a lack of clarity about boundaries. Questions like whether it's acceptable to share expenses, spend the night, or meet each other’s families might go unasked, leaving the nature of the relationship ambiguous and undefined. - Irregular or Superficial Communication
Communication in situationships can often be sporadic or shallow. For example, you may only receive a text once a week or have frequent but surface-level conversations that avoid deeper emotional topics. This lack of substantive connection can hinder any meaningful growth in the relationship. - Separation from Each Other’s Lives
Situationships often exist in a bubble, without integration into each other’s wider social or family circles. If you haven’t met their friends or family and vice versa, it’s a red flag that the relationship lacks deeper commitment and integration into each other’s lives. - Stagnation or No Future Discussion
If the relationship remains static, with no conversations about the future or long-term intentions, it’s likely a situationship. In these relationships, there’s often no progression toward something more meaningful, leaving both parties uncertain about what lies ahead.
In addition to these signs, Dr. Jenn Mann, writing for InStyle, identifies a few more markers of a situationship:
- Lack of Progression
Healthy relationships typically involve milestones, such as regular date nights, meeting friends and family, or discussing exclusivity. Situationships, however, often lack these natural steps forward, leaving the relationship stuck in a perpetual state of uncertainty. - Absence of Real Dates
Courtship is an essential part of dating, but in a situationship, you might find that your partner isn’t taking you out on genuine dates. If they frequently spend time with friends without inviting you or never make plans with you, it could signal a lack of investment in the relationship. - Superficial Connection
If your interactions remain shallow and your partner doesn’t seem interested in getting to know you deeply, it’s a sign that the emotional connection might be lacking. Without vulnerability and intimacy, the relationship will struggle to evolve into something more meaningful. - Inconsistent Plans
Situationships are often characterized by erratic, last-minute plans. While spontaneity can be exciting, a lack of planning may indicate that your partner isn’t committed to investing time and energy into building a deeper connection. - Exclusion from Special Events
If you’re attending family gatherings, holidays, or weddings alone, it could indicate that your partner doesn’t view you as their significant other. The inability to include you in important moments is a clear sign of the relationship’s lack of commitment. - Lack of Couple Status
A strong indicator that you’re in a situationship is when your partner’s friends and family are unaware of your existence. While this might be common early on, continued secrecy about the relationship can signal a problem. - Feelings of Anxiety or Boredom
The uncertainty and lack of commitment in situationships can lead to feelings of anxiety, especially when communication is inconsistent. Similarly, if the relationship feels limited to physical encounters and lacks emotional depth, you might start feeling bored or unfulfilled.
While situationships aren’t inherently good or bad, the experience ultimately depends on the individuals involved and their expectations. When both partners are aligned in what they want and are comfortable with the dynamic, situationships can be fulfilling. However, when there’s a disconnect in expectations, these relationships can negatively impact mental health and emotional well-being.
The Mental Health Impact of Situationships
The ambiguous nature and lack of communication in situationships can create frustration and confusion, often leaving those involved uncertain about where they stand. According to Anchor Therapy, any meaningful connection, whether positive or negative, will inevitably impact our mental and emotional well-being. In situationships, the absence of clear boundaries or defined roles can amplify this effect, leading to emotional and mental strain.
As relationships evolve, they typically progress through three stages: lust, attraction, and attachment. In a well-defined romantic connection, attachment is clear, allowing individuals to assess whether the relationship aligns with their romantic goals. However, in a situationship, these same stages can occur, but the relationship remains uncertain, which can leave one person more emotionally invested than the other. This imbalance can be especially challenging, as the lack of commitment makes it difficult for either partner to feel secure.
Furthermore, this emotional disconnect can lead to several mental health struggles. In a committed relationship, partners provide each other with emotional support and a sense of well-being, but situationships often fail to offer the same level of reassurance. As attachment deepens in an undefined connection, individuals may experience issues like low self-esteem and diminished self-worth due to the lack of emotional fulfillment. Additionally, spending significant time and emotional energy on a situationship that offers no clear commitment can lead to feelings of bitterness and futility.
Certified sex therapist and dating coach Michelle Herzog notes that the emotional uncertainty in situationships can cause persistent anxiety, stress, and a negative self-image. These feelings often stem from the inconsistency and lack of emotional connection, which can be mentally exhausting over time.
Interestingly, when searching for research on gay men and situationships, little to no specific studies were found comparing the relationship styles of gay and straight individuals. While it’s unclear whether gay men are more likely to engage in situationships, attachment theory may provide some insight since attachment styles—whether more secure or anxious—can play a significant role in why someone might enter a situationship. These styles influence how individuals approach intimacy and commitment, potentially explaining why certain people, including gay men, may find themselves in these ambiguous, emotionally taxing connections.
Major Red Flags in Situationships
When navigating a situationship, it's important to be mindful of potential red flags that could indicate an unhealthy dynamic. According to the Cleveland Health Clinic, several key signs may point to issues in these types of relationships.
- One-Sidedness
A major red flag is when one person holds more control or has different expectations from the other. This imbalance can create emotional strain and uncertainty. Reflecting on how you'd feel if the situationship ended tomorrow—and whether your partner would feel the same—can help assess the health of the relationship. - Feeling Underwhelmed
If you feel like you're only valued when your partner has nothing better to do or when they're seeking sex, it may suggest emotional neglect or disrespect. A situationship in which one partner shows little genuine care for the other can lead to feelings of being undervalued. - Dishonesty
Dishonesty can manifest in various ways, such as hiding aspects of your relationship from friends and family or avoiding public acknowledgment of your connection on social media. If your partner is unwilling to integrate you into their life or be open about your relationship, it may indicate a lack of commitment or transparency. - Fear of Communication or Vulnerability
A situationship where you're unable to express your wants or needs freely, or when conversations remain shallow, may point to a fear of vulnerability. Suppressing your true feelings out of fear of rejection or discomfort is often a sign of unhealthy communication patterns that can hinder emotional growth. - Manipulative Behavior or Game Playing
If your partner engages in manipulative behaviors, such as stringing you along with minimal communication or "breadcrumbing" (providing just enough attention to keep you interested), it suggests that they may not be fully invested in the relationship. This behavior is typical of toxic dynamics where one person is playing emotional games without genuine commitment.
Being aware of these red flags can help you evaluate whether your situationship is emotionally fulfilling or if it’s causing more harm than good. Recognizing these signs early on can lead to healthier relationship decisions moving forward.
How to Navigate a Situationship
If you find yourself in a situationship and aren't sure how to move forward, there are several steps you can take to assess the situation and make informed decisions. Dr. Michelle Herzog offers some valuable guidance on how to approach these uncertain connections.
- Pay Attention to Your Feelings
It's essential to be in tune with your emotional and physical responses during and after interactions. Take note of how you feel—whether you're relaxed, anxious, validated, or judged. If you consistently feel uneasy, it may be a sign that the situationship is not serving your emotional needs and may not be a healthy connection. - Have the Talk
Honest communication is key. It might be uncomfortable, but it's important to discuss your relationship goals with your partner to determine if they align. This conversation can help clarify whether you both want the same things. If your goals don't match, it doesn't mean either person is wrong, but it may indicate that the relationship is not compatible in the long term. - Make a Pros and Cons List
Objectively evaluate the situationship by listing the positives and negatives. Focus on significant factors like commitment and trust rather than minor shared interests. Even if the relationship has many good aspects, it's important to consider whether key issues, such as a lack of commitment, are dealbreakers for you. - Explore Your Options
Take a step back and ask yourself if the situationship is fulfilling your needs or if you're simply settling. Consider exploring other possibilities, whether that means dating other people or spending time on your own to reassess what you truly want in a relationship. - Give It Time, But Not Too Much
Allow the situationship some time—perhaps a month—to see if it develops further. After that period, reflect on whether you're satisfied with the relationship’s progress. If there are still red flags or you feel unfulfilled, it might be time to move on.
Breaking Up with a Situationship
If you've decided that the situationship isn't working for you, the next step is ending it in a direct and respectful manner. As Dr. Albers from the Cleveland Health Clinic suggests, it's important to be clear when communicating that the relationship is over. Avoid leaving things ambiguous, as sporadic or mixed messages can prolong confusion and emotional attachment.
Ending a situationship might feel emotionally complex, as it doesn't follow the same patterns as a traditional romantic breakup. It's normal to feel sad, and it's important to give yourself time to grieve. As we've discussed in previous episodes, acknowledging your emotions and allowing yourself space to heal is key to moving forward.
Here are a few additional steps to take when ending a situationship:
- Acknowledge the Complexity
Ending a situationship can feel different from ending a traditional relationship. It may not follow the typical breakup process, so be gentle with yourself during this transition. - Seek Internal Support
If you don't have a strong support system of friends who understand, focus on self-reflection to process the end of the situationship. Journaling and self-care can help you work through the emotions. - Reflect on Unmet Needs
Acknowledge that the situationship may have ended because your needs were not being met or because of incompatibility. This can help provide clarity and closure. - Pause and Journal
Take some time to write down your thoughts about what you learned from the situationship, what you gained, and what you’d like to avoid in future relationships. This reflective process can help you grow and better understand what you want moving forward. - Adopt a Growth Mindset
Instead of viewing the situationship as a failure, try to see it as a learning experience. Every relationship, whether short-term or long-term, contributes to your personal growth and relationship journey.
By following these steps, you can navigate the complexities of a situationship and, ultimately, make choices that support your emotional well-being and long-term relationship goals.
Navigating Situationships with Intention
Situationships can be fulfilling when both partners are aligned and clear about their expectations, but they can also hinder the possibility of forming a healthy, genuine relationship. If you often find yourself in unfulfilling situationships, it may be helpful to explore the underlying reasons, such as attachment styles, with the support of therapy.
In today's dating world, it’s easy to fall into familiar dynamics, but it’s crucial to evaluate whether they align with your long-term goals. Regularly evaluating your romantic experiences and ensuring they align with your long-term goals is essential for creating healthier, more fulfilling connections. Being intentional about your choices allows you to make decisions that nurture growth and personal fulfillment, instead of falling into familiar but unfulfilling patterns.
It's easy to get swept up in the excitement of initial attraction, but the best choices aren't always those that provide the most immediate satisfaction. Instead, focus on building a foundation for a genuine, secure connection that will serve your emotional well-being in the long run. By staying intentional about the choices we make in dating, we create the possibility for healthier, more meaningful relationships.
And remember: every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 128. Situationships: What's the Sitch?
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
