Am I Crying or Laughing?
We’re all too familiar with the “sassy gay best friend” trope—a character armed with campy humor and sharp wit, always ready with a quick comeback. While entertaining, these stereotypes have bled into real life, creating certain expectations that LGBTQ+ individuals will match this exaggerated personality.
Many of us have been there: we’re at a gathering, bantering, and someone laughs and says, “Oh my god, you’re hilarious.” And we smile and think, “Thanks, it’s probably the trauma.”
Jokes aside, humor varies for everyone, yet many people—gay or straight—often lean on self-deprecating humor. While self-awareness is important and a little lighthearted teasing can be harmless, humor can sometimes be a mask for deeper insecurities. When it becomes a go-to coping mechanism, it may actually take a toll on mental health, hinting at issues we may not even realize we're carrying.
Understanding Self-Deprecating Humor: A Coping Mechanism with Consequences
Self-deprecating humor, on the surface, may appear lighthearted, but beneath the laughs, it often hides something more complex. The term "self-deprecating" itself refers to the tendency to disparage or undervalue oneself, often by highlighting perceived personal flaws or failures. When humor is added, it seemingly softens the tone, making it more palatable for both the speaker and the audience. However, this kind of humor can have unintended effects on mental well-being.
Take, for instance, the insights shared by the University of Pittsburgh’s Supporting Our Valued Adolescents (SOVA) project. SOVA examines how humor, especially self-directed jokes, plays a role in the lives of young people dealing with depression and anxiety. They liken self-deprecating humor to the style of Chandler Bing from Friends, a character whose constant quips about his own insecurities mask deeper issues. This humor may provide brief relief or connection, but it often does so by fixating on negative self-perceptions, reinforcing insecurities rather than alleviating them.
Self-deprecating humor is especially popular among younger generations, as evidenced by an Arcadia University student’s observations. In a blog post, they describe how humor among friends often revolves around self-dismissive jokes—responses to questions like “Why did you do this?” might be met with, “Because I’m a disaster and don’t know what I’m doing!” This pattern of making light of one’s own shortcomings can blur the line between jokes and genuine self-doubt, especially for millennials who may struggle to express vulnerability without offsetting it with sarcasm or self-deprecating humor.
While self-deprecating humor can serve as a form of self-awareness, it can also perpetuate a cycle of self-criticism, especially when used excessively. In some cases, it can become a crutch that prevents genuine self-compassion, subtly impacting self-esteem and mental health.
Self-Deprecating Humor and Self-Esteem: A Connection Rooted in Social Survival
Self-deprecating humor surrounds us—whether it’s on TV, from friends, or our own words. But why do we engage in this type of humor? Is it just to entertain, or does it reveal something deeper? To understand this, we need to look at the role of self-esteem and how it shapes our social behaviors.
Psychologist Mark Leary’s 1999 study, published in Current Directions in Psychological Science, introduced the concept of the “sociometer theory,” which offers insight into the origins of self-esteem. According to Leary, self-esteem evolved as a psychological tool to gauge our social standing. Humans have an inherent drive to maintain meaningful relationships, a trait deeply rooted in our survival instincts. In early human societies, being part of a group meant safety and shared resources, while social rejection could lead to isolation and vulnerability.
The sociometer theory suggests that self-esteem functions as an internal gauge, monitoring our relationships and social acceptance. When we sense a threat to our acceptance—when we feel undervalued or perceive a shift in how others regard us—our “sociometer” sends an alert, pushing us to take steps to regain social approval. This response is somewhat akin to a “fight or flight” reaction in social terms, as we instinctively act to preserve our place in the group.
Humor, especially self-deprecating humor, becomes one way to address these social dynamics. By making light of our own perceived flaws or failures, we signal humility, reduce tension, and invite empathy or camaraderie, especially in situations where we fear judgment or rejection. While this humor can seem lighthearted, it often reflects an underlying attempt to safeguard our social bonds and maintain acceptance within our communities.
Humor as a Coping Mechanism: The Power and Pitfalls of Using Laughter to Manage Stress
Humor is often celebrated for its positive effects on well-being, functioning as a powerful tool to help manage stress and challenging emotions. Psych Central describes humor as an emotion-focused coping mechanism, a behavior used to offset the burden of stressful situations. Coping mechanisms like these allow us to adapt and respond to stressors, and they generally fall into four categories:
- Problem-focused coping targets the source of stress to solve or mitigate it.
- Meaning-focused coping attempts to find meaning in the stressful experience.
- Support-seeking coping involves reaching out to family, friends, or professionals.
- Emotion-focused coping, where humor fits in, aims to manage or reduce negative emotions associated with stress.
When humor is used healthily, it can be a constructive way to cope with life’s pressures. Examples of healthy humor include:
- Affiliative humor: This style uses lighthearted jokes and funny stories, fostering connection without offense.
- Positive reappraisal: This involves finding humor in a challenging situation to shift perspective, seeing it as a manageable challenge rather than a threat.
- Self-enhancing humor: This style reflects a general lightheartedness about life, like privately laughing at one’s own small missteps or quirks.
On the other hand, humor can sometimes take a negative turn, especially when it becomes self-defeating or self-deprecating. While this kind of humor might seem harmless, it can subtly reinforce insecurities over time. Aggressive humor, which involves jokes at the expense of others, also falls into the negative side of humor, as it may damage relationships or create tension.
Humor’s impact isn’t limited to daily stress. A 2015 study on trauma survivors of terror attacks found that using healthy humor styles was associated with reduced symptoms of trauma. By reframing serious events with lightheartedness, people might manage difficult emotions and lessen trauma’s impact. For those navigating heavy or traumatic experiences, humor may provide a brief reprieve, enabling them to process their emotions with a sense of resilience.
The Role of Humor in Coping with Trauma in the Gay Community
For many gay men, trauma is a familiar theme woven into the fabric of their lives. Growing up different often comes with feelings of shame and marginalization, leading many to adopt humor as a vital coping mechanism. This reliance on humor is not only a personal strategy but has also been embraced by the gay community for decades, serving as a means of resilience in the face of adversity.
In a 2019 article for Psychology Today, John-Manuel Andriote emphasizes humor’s significance in the lives of gay men. He notes that humor has been essential for navigating tough times and has historically provided a voice against societal oppression. For instance, camp humor, characterized by irony and theatricality, emerged in the 1920s as a way for gay men to express their anger and frustration over being marginalized. This style of humor became a tool for subversion, allowing individuals to confront and mock the constraints of polite society.
Andriote highlights how, during a period when legal options for asserting equality were scarce, camp humor offered a means to resist victimization, enabling gay men to reclaim their narratives and assert their humanity. Additionally, in the early 1990s, the ‘zine Diseased Pariah News was launched by gay men living with HIV and AIDS, using sharp, biting humor to challenge the stigma surrounding the disease. This form of humor served to redefine their identity, rejecting victimhood in favor of empowerment.
The power of humor extends beyond mere survival; it often shapes how the broader society perceives gay individuals. In a 1986 interview with Armistead Maupin, the renowned author of Tales of the City, he remarked on the paradox of being a gay humorist. While self-deprecating humor is a rich aspect of gay culture, it can be weaponized against the community when viewed through a critical lens.
More than three decades later, a 2018 study published in the Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental Health explored the coping strategies of LGBTQ+ youth in the face of pervasive stigma. The researchers found that, alongside avoiding problems, humor was a prominent coping strategy, along with relaxation techniques and emotional expression. This finding echoes the themes presented in earlier discussions about humor, reinforcing that while it can be a healthy outlet, the impact of humor—especially self-deprecating humor—depends significantly on its context and usage.
For the gay community, humor remains a powerful tool for resilience, offering a way to confront and navigate the complexities of identity and trauma. However, understanding the nuances of humor as a coping mechanism is crucial, as it can be both a source of strength and a potential pitfall, depending on how it is deployed.
Self-Deprecating Humor: A Coping Mechanism with Limits
Self-deprecating humor often serves as a go-to coping mechanism for dealing with negative emotions, but how effective is it in supporting mental well-being? A 2018 study in Personality and Individual Differences examined how humor impacts emotional regulation, particularly in managing anger. The researchers found that self-deprecating humor—directed at oneself—was linked to higher levels of internalized anger.
The study also noted associations between self-deprecating humor, increased anxiety, and depressive symptoms, suggesting that this form of humor might contribute to lower psychological well-being. The findings highlight that while self-deprecating humor can provide temporary relief or social connection, it may also carry unintended consequences when overused.
According to a 2019 article by Talkspace, there are several signs that self-deprecating humor might be causing harm rather than providing comfort, including:
- Difficulty Accepting Compliments: Struggling to accept compliments can indicate low self-esteem, as they may conflict with one's internalized negative beliefs or assumptions about others’ intentions.
- Automatic Self-Deprecation: When self-deprecating comments become reflexive rather than intentional, it may be time to reassess whether this humor is serving a constructive purpose or simply reinforcing negative self-perceptions.
- Uncomfortable Reactions from Others: If self-deprecating jokes frequently fall flat or make others uncomfortable, this could signal that the humor is becoming excessive or creating concern among friends or colleagues.
- Self-Deprecating When Alone: Negative self-talk, even when presented humorously, can become internalized over time, shaping one’s self-image in unhealthy ways.
- Believing the Punchlines: When self-deprecating humor shifts from light-hearted to a genuine self-perception, it stops being harmless. Instead of providing relief, it can reinforce insecurities and hinder self-esteem.
Break the Cycle of Self-Deprecating Humor
If you recognize some of the warning signs of self-deprecating humor in yourself, it may be a signal that deeper issues could be at play. One of the most effective ways to address these underlying feelings is through therapy, where a mental health professional can provide you with healthier coping strategies. In fact, therapy is often recommended as a first step in developing a positive relationship with oneself, and this applies well to reshaping self-perceptions impacted by self-deprecating humor.
In addition to therapy, Talkspace recommends several actionable steps to help break the cycle of self-deprecation:
- Accept Compliments Gracefully: When someone offers you a compliment, try to resist the urge to downplay or reject it. Instead, practice saying a simple "thank you." Additionally, make it a habit to compliment yourself, even if it feels uncomfortable at first; this can gradually reinforce a more positive self-view.
- Journal to Process and Reframe: Journaling can be a valuable outlet for processing self-deprecating thoughts. By writing down feelings, you can gain clarity and create opportunities to reframe negative thinking. Revisiting old entries to add new insights can also highlight personal growth and encourage a more balanced perspective on past situations.
- Encourage Others to Avoid Self-Deprecation: When friends or loved ones express self-deprecating thoughts, gently remind them to be kinder to themselves. This approach not only supports them in shifting their mindset but can also create a moment of self-reflection, prompting you to consider times when you, too, might have been overly critical of yourself.
Together, these small yet impactful actions can help shift self-deprecating humor from a habit rooted in insecurity to one rooted in self-acceptance and personal growth.
Embrace Healthy Humor
Humor can be a healthy coping tool, especially when it helps us process stress or connect with others, and a self-deprecating joke now and then isn’t necessarily harmful. However, it’s important to stay mindful of when self-criticism may be going too far, even under the guise of humor.
Most of us are familiar with self-deprecating humor, and many of us use it. But by practicing some of the strategies outlined—like accepting compliments, journaling to reframe thoughts, and treating ourselves with kindness—we can begin to break the cycle. Embrace your imperfections, and remember to be gentle with yourself. Show yourself the same grace you’d offer a friend.
And remember. Every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 33. Self-Deprecating Humor: Am I Crying or Laughing?.
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
