Queer Masculinity: Navigating Gay Men's Complex Relationship with Identity and Authenticity

Beyond the Brawn

Masculinity has long been a rigid societal construct, often excluding those who don't conform to traditional ideals. For gay men, navigating this pressure can be especially challenging, as they live within and outside of these gender expectations.

While the LGBTQ+ community has made significant progress in embracing individuality, internalized biases persist. Terms like “masc for masc” and “no fems” continue to circulate on dating apps, reinforcing the idea that desirability is tied to adhering to a specific form of masculinity. At the same time, gay men who are perceived as "straight-passing" may be criticized for not being “gay enough,” further complicating the navigation of their identity.

Erick DuPree, a literary anthropologist who explores the intersection of literature and culture, delves into the historical and cultural definitions of masculinity and their impact on identity. As they explain, “It’s not until the end of the 19th century and into the 20th century that we get sort of the ideal look of what masculinity is as we are currently defining it today." This narrow vision of masculinity leaves little room for vulnerability or self-exploration, which is particularly challenging for gay men who are often positioned outside traditional ideals.

The Burden of Binary Masculinity

The binary definition of masculinity has had a lasting effect, particularly for queer men. Historically, same-sex attraction existed alongside traditional societal roles, such as marriage and fatherhood, without the rigid categorization seen today. However, the industrialization of the 19th and 20th centuries cemented a more hyper-masculine ideal, one that positioned strength, dominance, and stoicism as central characteristics of masculinity.

This industrialized form of masculinity has resulted in widespread bullying, ridicule, and rejection for many gay men who do not conform to these expectations. As Erick notes, this societal shift has led to the creation of "proto-masculinity," a performance many gay men adopt to fit in. This performance, often influenced by cultural figures like Tom of Finland or The Village People, becomes a survival mechanism in response to social pressures.

However, the idea that masculinity must be rigidly defined continues to thrive, extending beyond the queer community. Movements promoting a return to "primal manhood" in contemporary media demonstrate how deeply ingrained these narratives remain. For many gay men, this notion of masculinity represents another form of assimilation. The challenge lies in embracing a more fluid understanding of masculinity, one that allows for personal authenticity.

The Performance of Masculinity

The societal pressure to perform masculinity within the gay community can be especially pervasive, leading to exaggerated expressions of masculinity in an attempt to fit a perceived ideal. As Erick points out, “We create these proto-ideas of proto-masculinity, and then we force them on ourselves to not be something else.” Many gay men modify their voices, mannerisms, and fashion choices to align with a specific vision of manhood, often unknowingly.

This performance of masculinity is not only shaped by personal experiences of rejection or bullying but is also deeply influenced by media portrayals of masculinity. From the action heroes of the 1980s to the rugged, muscular men in the work of Tom of Finland, these cultural representations reinforce the notion that masculinity is synonymous with strength, dominance, and emotional restraint. This has been commodified within gay culture, where hyper-masculinity is both celebrated and sold, leaving many gay men struggling with the pressure to embody these traits.

However, modern conversations surrounding gender identity are shifting. Younger generations are increasingly rejecting strict binaries in favor of fluidity in self-expression. Additionally, the visibility of figures like Jonathan Van Ness and Alok Vaid-Menon—who blend masculinity and femininity—illustrates a cultural shift toward a broader, more inclusive understanding of gender identity.

The Feminine Divine and Its Role in Gay Men’s Relationship with Masculinity

Throughout history, many gay men have found solace in spirituality that emphasizes feminine energies, often as a counter to the rigid masculinity imposed by society. Goddess-based traditions revered feminine power and even recognized queer individuals as spiritually significant. As Erick explains, “There are definitely queer cults to the Goddess throughout history. In the cult of Inanna in Sumeria, trans people were like divine.”

In modern times, many gay men connect with the feminine divine through popular culture figures who embody resilience, transformation, and unapologetic self-expression. Icons like Madonna, Beyoncé, and Mariah Carey serve not only as entertainment figures but as symbols of empowerment, self-discovery, and strength. These "divas," whose names come from the Italian word for "goddess," provide a framework for many gay men to navigate their identities in a world that often marginalizes them.

Erick suggests that embracing both masculine and feminine aspects allows gay men to break free from the limiting confines of societal gender expectations. This combination of traits, represented by both divinity and authenticity, offers a pathway to self-empowerment and community connection.

The Shared Struggles of Gay Men and Women in a Patriarchal Society

Both gay men and women have historically experienced systemic oppression under patriarchal structures. While their struggles are not identical, there is significant overlap in their experiences of discrimination, objectification, and societal control. As Erick notes, “The women’s liberation struggle and the queer liberation struggle intersected a lot.” Both movements have fought for autonomy over their bodies and the right to exist outside societal expectations.

This shared struggle has fostered solidarity between gay men and women, especially in the fight against systemic discrimination. However, despite these alliances, misogyny continues to persist within gay male culture. This reflection of ingrained biases reinforces the need for greater solidarity and mutual respect between the two groups in order to continue advancing the fight for equality.

Mindfulness, Meditation, and Reconnecting with Authenticity

For gay men, societal pressures around masculinity can create deep internal conflict. The tension between societal expectations of toughness and the vulnerability within their identities can lead to emotional and psychological challenges. Mindfulness and meditation offer an opportunity to reconnect with the self in a way that isn’t governed by societal ideals of masculinity.

Erick explains that mindfulness allows individuals to return to their most authentic selves, offering a gentle reconnection with their true identity. This process of self-reflection provides gay men with a way to move beyond societal pressures and embrace their full, authentic identities. Alongside mindfulness, therapy plays a crucial role in healing the psychological scars of societal rejection, enabling gay men to rediscover their true selves without the burden of external validation.

Embracing Femininity and Authenticity in Gay Men

Navigating the pressure of societal masculinity can often leave gay men feeling disconnected from their true selves. However, true growth and healing come when individuals look inward to understand their authentic identity, free from the constraints of external expectations. It's easy to feel overwhelmed by the prospect of forging a clear sense of self, but it's important to recognize that this journey doesn't have to be rushed.

Creating an authentic life is about taking one step at a time, allowing space for self-discovery without the pressure of immediate perfection. Each small step, no matter how seemingly insignificant, leads toward a more genuine existence. By embracing both masculine and feminine aspects within, gay men can build the confidence and clarity necessary to live fully in alignment with who they are. This ongoing process of reflection and openness creates a deeper connection to self and others, allowing for the expansion of both personal and communal boundaries.

And remember: every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.

For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 89. Beyond the Brawn: Redefining Queer Masculinity (with Erick DuPree).

Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.