Won't You Take Me to Provincetown?
Provincetown, Massachusetts, known for its picturesque beaches and vibrant arts scene, has long been a beloved destination for the LGBTQ+ community. Nestled at the tip of Cape Cod, this historic town has transformed from a secluded fishing village to one of the most iconic gay destinations in the United States.
With its welcoming atmosphere, rich cultural heritage, and progressive spirit, Provincetown offers a unique blend of natural beauty, artistic expression, and a deep sense of inclusivity that has made it a cornerstone of LGBTQ+ tourism. Whether for a relaxing getaway, a lively nightlife scene, or a celebratory wedding destination, Provincetown continues to be a place where all are invited to embrace their true selves.
The History and Evolution of Provincetown
Located at the northern tip of Cape Cod, Provincetown has a rich history that shaped its cultural and economic landscape. Originally inhabited by the Wampanoag, Nauset, and Paomet tribes, the area's bountiful waters made it a hub for fishing and trade.
According to Kinlin Grover, in 1614, Captain John Smith charted the area and named the harbor Milford Haven, which was later used by the Mayflower's captain to guide the Pilgrims. The Mayflower first anchored in Provincetown Harbor in 1620, but tensions with the local Paomet tribe over stolen corn led the Pilgrims to move to Plymouth.
By the late 1600s, Provincetown’s harbor became a haven for seafarers, fishermen, and pirates. Its remote nature earned it the nickname "Helltown," as it was a refuge from the strict Puritanical social order. In the 1700s, Provincetown became part of Truro and was officially incorporated in 1727. Although whaling brought prosperity in the 1800s, the town’s economy struggled in the 1890s due to the rise of the oil industry and other economic challenges.
Despite these setbacks, Provincetown’s tourism industry grew, aided by established hotels, steamship service, and a railway link. The town’s transformation into an arts colony began in 1899 with the opening of the Cape Cod School of Painting, attracting artists like Hans Hoffman and writers such as Norman Mailer. This arts community fostered a sense of freedom and acceptance, setting the stage for Provincetown’s evolution as an LGBTQ+ destination.
By the 1960s, Provincetown became a popular haven for the LGBTQ+ community. Its progressive reputation was solidified in 2004 when Massachusetts became the first state to legalize same-sex marriage, and Provincetown became a top wedding destination for same-sex couples. Today, Provincetown’s blend of Indigenous history, maritime commerce, arts culture, and LGBTQ+ inclusivity mirrors other iconic LGBTQ+ locales, like Fire Island.
Provincetown's Artistic Roots and LGBTQ+ Transformation
Provincetown’s journey from a quiet fishing village to an iconic LGBTQ+ destination is closely intertwined with its rich artistic history. According to the New England Historical Society, the town's artistic evolution began in 1899 with the opening of the Cape Cod School of Art, followed by the Summer School of Painting in 1900. These institutions attracted a wave of free thinkers, including notable gay artists like Marsden Hartley and Charles Demuth, who, according to the New England Historical Society, helped shape Provincetown into a center of creative expression. By the early 20th century, Provincetown had become a haven for artists and intellectuals, including individuals from Greenwich Village, bringing new ideas and energy to the area.
One of the most pivotal moments in this cultural shift occurred during the "Great Summer" of 1916, as Marsden Hartley described it. Artists who had spent time in European cities like Berlin, Paris, and London returned to Provincetown after the outbreak of World War I, bringing with them a taste of the sexually liberated atmospheres they had experienced abroad. The town became home to six art schools, and a vibrant community of artists, writers, and performers—such as John Dos Passos, John Reed, and Eugene O'Neill—flocked to Provincetown, creating a lasting cultural legacy.
Provincetown’s Emergence as a Gay Haven
By 1940, Provincetown had firmly established itself as both an arts colony and a gay haven. This was underscored by the arrival of playwright Tennessee Williams, whose presence marked a significant cultural moment in the town's history. In his reflections on Provincetown, Williams described the town's diversity, identifying four distinct groups within the LGBTQ+ community: flamboyant gay visitors, elite artists and writers, gay "wash-ashores" who had settled year-round, and the local native gay population. This insight highlights the town's complex and inclusive LGBTQ+ identity, which would continue to evolve over the decades.
The town’s cultural evolution also extended to language and representation. In 1940, Provincetown’s newspaper, The Provincetown Advocate, became one of the first publications to use the word “homosexual,” a term that wouldn't appear in the New York Times until 1967. This milestone marked Provincetown’s early role in embracing LGBTQ+ culture and language, setting the stage for its eventual recognition as a safe and welcoming space for the queer community.
Pivotal LGBTQ+ Milestones in Provincetown’s History
Provincetown’s significance as an LGBTQ+ destination continued to grow throughout the 20th century. In 1966, renowned artist Andy Warhol brought his multimedia performance, Exploding Plastic Inevitable, to Provincetown, featuring the Velvet Underground. As noted by the Provincetown Business Guild, this groundbreaking event played a key role in elevating Provincetown’s status as a cultural hub for both art and LGBTQ+ culture.
That same year, drag performer Lynne Carter purchased The Pilgrim House, a historic venue dating back to 1810. While Carter’s ownership isn't always highlighted in the venue's official history, her performances were integral to shaping Provincetown’s cultural landscape in the 1960s and 1970s.
The early 1970s marked a significant period of LGBTQ+ activism in Provincetown. In 1970, despite being denied a parade permit, LGBTQ+ activists organized a Labor Day Solidarity March to commemorate the first anniversary of the Stonewall riots. Provincetown also became home to the first Fantasia Fair in 1975, which later became the world’s longest-running transgender event, founded by Ariadne Kane. As the Digital Transgender Archive notes, Fantasia Fair brought national attention to transgender rights and became a pioneering event in transgender activism.
Provincetown as a Hub for LGBTQ+ Culture and Activism
In addition to artistic and cultural developments, Provincetown became a focal point for LGBTQ+ activism and progress. In 1976, Womencrafts, a lesbian-owned bookstore promoting female authors and artisans, opened its doors, and in 1978, the Provincetown Business Guild (PBG) was established. The PBG played a pivotal role in both supporting local businesses and promoting LGBTQ+ tourism. It was also instrumental in creating the Provincetown Carnival, which remains an iconic week-long celebration of community, expression, and creativity.
The 1980s saw Provincetown further solidify its status as an LGBTQ+ sanctuary with the founding of the Provincetown AIDS Support Group (now the AIDS Support Group of Cape Cod) in 1983, providing vital care and support for those affected by the HIV/AIDS crisis. The decade also saw significant protests, such as the 1990 Spiritus Riot, which erupted in response to the arrest of drag performer Vanilla. The protest led to reforms within the Provincetown Police Department, including the hiring of LGBTQ+ officers, marking a shift in local law enforcement's approach to the LGBTQ+ community.
Provincetown in the 21st Century: A Modern LGBTQ+ Beacon
In the early 2000s, Provincetown continued to serve as a destination for niche LGBTQ+ communities, such as the bear community. In 2001, Provincetown Bear Week was created by John Burrows and the P Town Bears organization, which has since grown into the largest gathering of bears in the world, attracting tens of thousands of attendees each year.
Provincetown also became a central hub for the fight for marriage equality. In 2004, Provincetown made headlines when it became one of the first places in the country to welcome couples seeking to marry after Massachusetts legalized same-sex marriage. By 2010, Provincetown was officially recognized as having the highest rate of same-sex couples in the U.S., earning it the title of "the gayest town in America."
The Ongoing Evolution of Provincetown: A Journey of Resilience and Reinvention
Provincetown’s journey from a rowdy port for sailors and fishermen to a thriving arts colony and eventual LGBTQ+ destination serves as a testament to its resilience and adaptability. Over the years, the town has weathered economic downturns, the decline of the whaling industry, and devastating storms, but it has always found a way to evolve.
Like the town itself, our personal and collective journeys toward achieving long-term goals are often not linear. There will be moments of setback, like Provincetown’s economic struggles, or personal storms that leave us picking up the pieces. However, these challenges can also provide opportunities for reinvention.
Just as Provincetown transformed into a cultural haven, we too can channel our strengths, embrace creative solutions, and think outside the box to achieve our objectives. Life doesn’t always follow the expected path, but by trusting in our own resilience and capabilities, we can continue to make progress toward our goals in unexpected and meaningful ways.
And remember. Every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 114. Provincetown.
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
