Hidden in Plain Sight
In the vibrant yet turbulent 1920s, New York City’s underground gay nightlife began to take shape in secretive, illicit spaces. These venues, known as gay speakeasies, became critical sanctuaries for LGBTQ+ individuals during an era that criminalized their existence. The gay speakeasy scene flourished within the broader context of Prohibition, which restricted alcohol consumption and gave rise to hidden bars that catered to all manner of rebellious clientele. Amidst jazz music, drag performances, and defiance of societal norms, these clandestine clubs offered queer individuals the rare opportunity to express their identities and forge meaningful community ties.
Chris Holcombe, author of the Hidden Gotham series, provides a compelling look at the underground world of 1920s Greenwich Village. His work brings to light the rich yet fraught history of these speakeasies and their intersection with organized crime. The Mafia played a significant role in sustaining these venues, as they provided alcohol and protection from law enforcement, allowing these queer spaces to endure despite the risks. These hidden clubs became more than just places of refuge; they were centers of queer culture and resistance, marking an era of resilience and creativity that would inspire future generations of LGBTQ+ individuals.
The Allure of Gay Speakeasies
The 1920s was a decade defined by social upheaval, innovation, and rebellion. Prohibition, combined with the aftermath of World War I and the influenza pandemic, created a climate ripe for defiance. Speakeasies, including those catering to the LGBTQ+ community, emerged as spaces where social norms were both challenged and celebrated. The secretive nature of these venues allowed individuals to experiment with their identities in ways that would have been impossible in the public eye.
While the broader speakeasy scene included all manner of illicit activities, LGBTQ+ spaces were particularly important for marginalized individuals seeking refuge. These hidden clubs were often the only places where same-sex love could be expressed openly, albeit under the protection of coded language and discreet practices. Queer patrons used subtle signals, such as specific clothing items or coded language, to identify one another and gain entry to these secretive spaces. Word of mouth, secret knocks, and private invitations ensured that these venues remained protected from the prying eyes of law enforcement and anti-vice organizations.
A Culture of Resistance and Expression
The defiance exhibited in these speakeasies extended beyond just the consumption of alcohol. They became centers of creative expression, with performances that challenged gender norms and blurred the lines between masculinity and femininity. Drag shows, in particular, were central to this culture, offering a public platform for individuals to defy societal expectations and engage in subversive performances. Artists such as Barbette, a cross-dressing aerialist, captivated audiences with daring performances that pushed the boundaries of gender and identity.
In Harlem, a cultural renaissance was underway, where queer individuals and Black Americans, both marginalized in different ways, found solidarity. As artists and musicians, they sought refuge and artistic expression in Harlem's speakeasies, where spaces of mutual respect and creativity flourished.
Ma Rainey, the "Mother of the Blues," and Bessie Smith, the "Empress of the Blues," were key figures in this cultural movement. Known for their unapologetic performances that often defied gender norms and explored complex relationships, these two trailblazers helped lay the groundwork for Harlem’s inclusivity. Both women, whose music spoke to themes of love, desire, and rebellion, became symbols of defiance and empowerment, resonating deeply with both the LGBTQ+ and Black communities.
Ball Culture: A Space for Queer Liberation
Emerging alongside Harlem's jazz clubs and gay speakeasies, ball culture became a critical form of self-expression for Black and Latinx LGBTQ+ individuals. Ballrooms were places where participants, known as "ball queens" and "butch queens," would compete in elaborate costume contests, often performing in categories that celebrated gender fluidity, racial identity, and artistic creativity. This culture was born out of the desire for queer liberation and a rejection of societal norms that sought to suppress marginalized identities.
The Harlem ballrooms were an especially important space for LGBTQ+ people of color, providing a sense of belonging and community in a world that often rejected them. The performances at these balls blurred the boundaries of gender and sexuality, allowing individuals to explore different facets of their identities through the art of voguing—a highly stylized dance that emphasized dramatic posing and expression. For many, the ballrooms became a home, a safe space where they could be celebrated for their uniqueness rather than ostracized.
The Mafia’s Role in the Survival of Gay Speakeasies
While gay speakeasies were crucial for providing sanctuary and self-expression, their existence also relied on strategic alliances with organized crime. With the onset of Prohibition, the Mafia became a central force in supplying alcohol to these venues, ensuring their survival in a time when alcohol was banned. In exchange for alcohol, these speakeasies often paid the Mafia for protection—shielding patrons from law enforcement and safeguarding the venue from raids.
The Mafia's involvement was not motivated by altruism, but rather by the opportunity to profit from these illegal operations. However, this partnership allowed gay speakeasies to persist and thrive, providing a vital space for LGBTQ+ individuals to gather, express their identities, and form community connections during a period of intense social and legal repression. This connection between organized crime and gay bars would continue into the 1960s, culminating in events like the Stonewall Riots.
Subtle Signals and Codes: Navigating the Hidden World of Gay Speakeasies
To access these hidden queer spaces, individuals had to be resourceful. The underground nature of gay speakeasies meant that access was often granted through a network of social connections and coded communication.
Word of mouth was the primary way information about gay speakeasies spread, with trusted individuals acting as gatekeepers, inviting newcomers into these secretive venues. To ensure their safety and privacy, speakeasies employed layers of protection, such as secret knocks, passwords, and invitations from regular patrons. These measures were essential for maintaining the security of those seeking refuge.
In addition to these physical barriers, subtle cues and coded communication played a significant role in signaling one’s identity. Gay men, for example, often used feminine pronouns when referring to each other—a practice originally developed to conceal romantic conversations in public, but which later became a defining feature of queer vernacular. This allowed individuals to express their identities discreetly while fostering a sense of solidarity.
Fashion also became a silent language of identity. In the vibrant 1920s, small deviations in style, like brightly colored accessories or flamboyant twists on conventional outfits, served as visual signals of queerness. These subtle clues, such as a patterned scarf or a bold hat, invited like-minded individuals to connect. In cities like Paris, monocles became a widely recognized symbol of lesbian identity, and similar fashion cues emerged in other queer-friendly locations. The practice of "dropping pins" also gained traction, referring to the act of offering subtle hints or cues—similar to dropping a hairpin—to gauge mutual interest.
Media also played a part in this covert communication. Lois Long’s Tables for Two column in The New Yorker provided discreet references to queer spaces in the city, subtly hinting at the existence of LGBTQ+ venues without directly naming them. Through her coded language and allusions, Long helped to guide readers who were in the know toward these secretive havens.
Embracing Queer Joy: The Lasting Legacy of Gay Speakeasies
The gay speakeasies of the 1920s, though born out of necessity and the desire for safe spaces, also served as a reminder of the importance of finding joy and celebration even in challenging times. In many ways, these reticent venues mirrored the resilience of the queer community, offering more than just a refuge from discrimination. They provided a sanctuary where joy, camaraderie, and self-expression could flourish without fear.
As we navigate our own struggles today, particularly in the face of political and social challenges, it’s important to remember that the fight for visibility and rights is ongoing—but so is the need for celebration. Just as the queer community of the 1920s found moments of reprieve and freedom amidst adversity, we too must make space to nurture queer joy. By connecting with one another and embracing the beauty of our identities, we ensure our voices are not only heard but that we also live fully and authentically—balancing the work of advocacy with the power of pure, unfiltered joy.
And remember: every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 136. Closets & Cocktails: The Secret History of Gay Speakeasies (with Chris Holcombe).
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
