Raise Your Hand If You've Ever Been Personally Victimized by a Gay Regina George
In a world already rife with hate and divisiveness, the LGBTQ+ community often finds itself battling external prejudices while simultaneously grappling with internal tensions. Among gay men, the stereotype of the "bitchy queen" or "mean gays" trope has become both a cultural fixture and a point of contention. Rooted in sharp wit and biting humor, this behavior is often celebrated in pop culture, yet it can carry an undercurrent of deeper issues.
For many gay men, these experiences have shaped their identities, fostering a defensive armor that manifests as shade or critique. While some see it as playful banter, others feel it reinforces a cycle of judgment that can isolate and harm. Now more than ever, as our community faces ongoing challenges, it’s time to reexamine these behaviors and consider how we can replace competition with compassion.
Examining Competitiveness and Judgment in the LGBTQ+ Community
The stereotype of gay men being mean, catty, or judgmental has persisted for decades. While often exaggerated for comedic effect in pop culture, it’s a phenomenon with real roots in the shared experiences of many gay men. Surprisingly, there’s little scientific research on this behavior, but perspectives from thought leaders and community members shed light on its possible causes.
Dr. Alan Downs, author of The Velvet Rage, suggests that the need to project perfection—whether through career success, physical appearance, or social status—often stems from shame experienced during adolescence. This "beautifully curated illusion" isn’t always a conscious choice but can serve as a coping mechanism for unresolved feelings of inadequacy. Success, while admirable, can sometimes function as a way to mask deeper vulnerabilities.
In a 2015 HuffPost article, Barrett Pall links competitiveness in the gay community to the transition many gay men make when moving to more inclusive environments. Cities and queer-friendly spaces offer opportunities for connection, but they also create social pressure. Pall notes that this pressure is amplified by the fragmentation of the gay community into subgroups—like twink, bear, or masc—each with its own stereotypes and hierarchies. These divisions can lead to cliques that reinforce exclusivity and judgment.
Adding another layer, Zachary Zane writes in a 2016 Pride article that childhood bullying often leaves gay men with lingering insecurities. For many, excelling in academics or athletics was a means of escape, leading to habits of overachievement and comparison. When combined with the interconnectedness of queer social circles—where friendships, exes, and professional ties often overlap—it’s easy to see how competitiveness can give way to cattiness or mean-spirited behavior.
Ultimately, some gay men may act mean or judgy as a form of self-defense. Whether consciously or unconsciously, being critical of others can serve as a way to avoid vulnerability or establish dominance within social dynamics. It’s a way of saying, “I’ll hurt you before you can hurt me.”
How Internalized Homophobia Fuels Mean Gay Behavior
The stereotype of the “bitchy queen” has been a staple of LGBTQ+ representation in media, often portrayed through quick-witted, sassy characters. While these depictions can be humorous on-screen, they’ve also contributed to real-life dynamics where judgment and cattiness sometimes replace support and camaraderie within the gay community. But where does this behavior come from? Experts and commentators suggest it may stem from deeper, internalized struggles.
In a 2013 Advocate article, Carl Sandle posits that internalized homophobia plays a significant role in mean gay behavior. Rejection from society often leaves gay men with feelings of inadequacy, which can manifest as judgment or exclusion of others within the community. Rather than addressing their own pain, some redirect it outward through cutting remarks or cliquish behavior.
J. Bryan Lowder, in a 2014 Slate video, expands on this idea, describing “bitchiness” as a defense mechanism. For generations, humor, sarcasm, and shade have been tools gay men use to shield themselves from a hostile world. While this wit can foster connection and resilience, it can also contribute to toxic interactions when misused.
Michael Musto’s 2016 Out article examines when the “bitchy queen” archetype becomes harmful. While entertaining in fiction, this trope often spills into real life, where it stops being lighthearted banter and starts reinforcing exclusionary behavior. Musto highlights how playful cattiness can cross a line, fostering toxicity in gay social circles.
Social dynamics within the gay community also exacerbate these behaviors. In a 2017 HuffPost article, Jonny Harvey discusses how social status, appearance, and wealth become criteria for acceptance in certain gay cliques. Apps, social media, and nightlife amplify these hierarchies, creating environments reminiscent of high school cliques but with higher stakes.
This culture of exclusion isn’t just harmful to individuals—it also perpetuates stereotypes that paint gay men as shallow or self-absorbed. A 2022 Polyester Zine article notes that how we treat each other within the gay community often mirrors how society at large treats us. As a marginalized group facing daily hate and criticism, gay men can’t afford to tear each other down.
How Gay Men Can Build Each Other Up
Instead of perpetuating the cycle of hurt, we should strive to create a culture of support and kindness within the gay community. But how do we get there? It starts by tackling one of the root causes of division: comparison.
Psychotherapist Matthew J. Dempsey, in his YouTube video, explains the “compare and despair” phenomenon, where competition among gay men often leads to feelings of inadequacy and division. He emphasizes that this rivalry undermines the solidarity we should have as a community. To counteract this, Dempsey suggests practices like appreciating what we have, focusing on gratitude, replacing comparative thoughts with constructive ones, prioritizing what truly matters, and documenting our personal achievements to celebrate progress rather than comparison.
Beyond addressing comparison, fostering kindness is essential. While there’s no manual for being a kinder gay man, general principles of kindness can guide us. Empathy is key—taking the time to see situations from others’ perspectives and understanding their emotions can go a long way. Active listening, positive reinforcement, generosity, gratitude, forgiveness, and respectful behavior are all cornerstones of kindness that we can adopt in our daily interactions.
Practicing kindness doesn’t require grand gestures; small acts can make a big impact. Hold the door open for someone, offer your time or resources to those in need, and be mindful of your words by avoiding gossip and negative comments. Simple actions like making eye contact, smiling, and being present in conversations can also convey genuine care and connection.
Overcoming Division in the LGBTQ+ Community
The LGBTQ+ community is rich in diversity, with a wide range of identities, experiences, and challenges that shape its members. While this diversity is a strength, it requires intentional efforts to foster unity and mutual support. Embracing inclusivity and addressing exclusionary behaviors are essential for creating an environment where everyone feels valued and supported. By promoting a culture of compassion and understanding, we can ensure that every individual has the support they need to thrive through the following key actions:
- Embrace Intersectionality: Understand that each person's journey within the LGBTQ+ community is shaped by factors like race, gender identity, and socioeconomic status. Educate ourselves about the disparities these intersections create.
- Practice Inclusive Advocacy: Use inclusive language, support LGBTQ+ businesses and events, and create safe spaces in workplaces and public spaces.
- Listen and Amplify: Actively listen to and validate the experiences of others, challenge stereotypes, donate to key organizations, and advocate for policy changes that support all members of the LGBTQ+ community.
- Stand Against Division: Reject attempts to fragment the community. Discrimination against one group impacts all. Stand up against anti-trans and anti-drag legislation, even if it doesn't directly affect you.
- Commit to Solidarity: Advocate for the rights of every LGBTQ+ individual, recognizing that unity and collective action are essential to resist both external and internal discrimination.
Breaking the Cycle and Cultivating Kindness in the LGBTQ+ Community
Being caught in cycles of judgment, hurt, and insecurity can keep us out of sync with those around us. Whether we've been the ones to dish out the sharp words or the ones on the receiving end, it's time for us to stop the negativity. Hurt people hurt people, and many of us carry internalized homophobia and shame from years of societal rejection. But we have the power to break free from that cycle.
Instead of letting shame dictate how we treat others, we can work toward healing—whether through therapy, self-reflection, or simply choosing to be kinder to ourselves and others. When we take the time to work through our own hurt, we create space to build each other up, rather than tearing each other down. In doing so, we can embrace authenticity, happiness, and kindness, not just for ourselves but for those around us.
In a world that often feels uncertain, let’s choose to be the source of positivity and support in our community. Let’s uplift each other, amplify diverse voices, and be there for one another when times get tough. Together, we can create a space where trust and kindness thrive, ensuring that we are not just surviving, but truly thriving, as we navigate our identities together.
And remember: every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 135. Don't Be A Mean Gay.
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
